May 06, 2017

Where Did Patch Finish? Kentucky Derby's One-Eyed Horse Wins Hearts

The most-talked-about horse at the Kentucky Derby was a half-blind colt named Patch. You can guess who we were rooting for.

Patch, the horse | Getty Images

The most-talked-about horse heading into Saturday's Kentucky Derby wasn't the oddsmakers' favorite and winner, Always Dreaming. It was the one-eyed Bay Colt whose victory in the Run for the Roses would've been an unlikely dream come true. Patch, a 3-year-old novice in high-stakes races, may not have won the race, but he clearly won hearts across the country.

Introduced Saturday evening to the Kentucky Derby crowd at Churchill Downs, the crowd let out an emotional, throaty cheer for Patch. After a less-than-three-minute race on a sloppy track, Patch finished 14th.

Of course, the folks at this Patch fell in love with the plucky, half-blind youngster, too, from our newsroom to the boardroom. There's just something about an underdog who keeps running, and running, and running — though the experts didn't give him a chance in hell of competing, let alone winning — that appealed to us. Maybe it's the affection millions of fans feel for Patch, too, that moved us.

Whatever the reason, we pooled our hard-earned pennies and bet on Patch. A week out, the odds were 40-1, but at post time, the odds were 13-1. The heart wants what the heart wants, it would seem, and many lovestruck gamblers wanted Patch to see his way to the Derby's finish line first. More than $2 million was wagered on his unlikely victory.

The Sporting News fell in love with Patch, too, just for his name. Out of the 20 Kentucky Derby entrants, Patch's name was ranked as the best name.

"He's what you would call a beloved old faithful dog. And as the one-eyed 30-to-1 "dark horse" everyone loves ... it's hard to find a sweeter name than that."

The horse was named Patch before a mysterious ailment struck his left eye one year ago. Swollen shut and seeping, a veterinarian treated the eye with antibiotics for a few weeks before deciding the eye couldn't be saved. Patch was in a lot of pain. The eye was removed in June 2016.

“It was heartbreaking for me,” his trainer, Todd Pletcher, told Thoroughbred Today. Pletcher was afraid the horse would need a lot of retraining, too. His dad, J.J. Pletcher, took up the cause in Ocala, Florida.

"I was concerned that it might compromise his ability in some way or the way he carried himself," Pletcher said in an interview with USA Today this week. "If you watched him train and didn't know that he had one eye, there’s no indication of him doing anything peculiar in his training or in his races that would make you concerned about the one eye."

A few weeks in, according to Bloodhorse.com, the Pletchers realized one eye was just as good as two for this horse. He didn't need special training.

He started in the 20th post position, which meant all the horses were positioned to his blind side to start the race. Patch has run in just a handful of races, but he's run well. He recently finished second in the Louisiana Derby

According to his Derby bio:

Patch provided an impressive performance in only running twice prior to his start in the Louisiana Derby, which happens to be his first graded stakes. He previously ran in two maiden special weight races at Gulfstream Park in January and February of 2017, finishing a close second in one and winning the other.A second-place finish for Patch in the Louisiana Derby earned him 40 qualifying points on the Road to the Kentucky Derby, putting him in 11th place with a month to go until the 143rd edition of the Run for the Roses.

Patch is "a really, really cool horse to be around," Pletcher told Bloodhorse. "Very professional, very straight forward, easy to train. He's just a consummate pro."

No matter where Patch finished, Pletcher got to celebrate. Always Dreaming was a Pletcher horse, too.

Go Patch! You keep dreaming! And so will we.